Giving an innocent the traitor's knife.

[memo3300]

Soo... i was playing TTT after months of not being able to play, and i find this lil' problem.

One guy was saying that Xrain told him that a tratitor giving a innocent his knife wasn't something bad.

But, teeny said that we shouldn't listen to xrain if he said that, and that if we do it we will get banned.

For meh, I belive giving away the knife is wrong, and making it bannable would prevent having to hear a guy raging because he lost karma or got RDMed for something unfair.

anyways, what do you guys think?

[jimonions]

counts as ghosting, in my opinion is bannable.

[Deacon]

Soo... i was playing TTT after months of not being able to play, and i find this lil' problem.

One guy was saying that Xrain told him that a tratitor giving a innocent his knife wasn't something bad.

But, teeny said that we shouldn't listen to xrain if he said that, and that if we do it we will get banned.

For meh, I belive giving away the knife is wrong, and making it bannable would prevent having to hear a guy raging because he lost karma or got RDMed for something unfair.

anyways, what do you guys think?

I don't think xrain said this and if he did then i'm afraid i would have to disagree.
Working with T's as innocent IS bannable.
And giving the innocent the knife will only get them killed by the other innocents. Or they will use it on the other innocents.
Its just going to cause a problem with false traitors and karma baiting (eg, trolling)

[ursus]

Teaming up is a ban.
Ghosting is a ban.
Anything that deviates from the normal rules and game mechanics is a ban.

[Deathie]

I actually worked out a strategy becuase people do this so often.


> I'm a traitor
> Run around with knife
> go "I FOUND IT ON THE FLOOR"
> everyone believes you

Seriously.

[Orgazmo]

I could see how giving an innocent a knife and "teaming up" would be bad but I would think leaving a knife on the ground to be picked up in certain situations would be a legitimate strategy to cause confusion and disarray in the ranks of the innocents before or while you strike.

[Moo]

k lets clear this up

a traitor giving an innocent a knife, BOTH KNOWING... is not ghosting, there are no dead(ghosts) involved in the situation
this is not allowed, the game mode was not designed for traitors and innocents/detectives to team up

and to Orgazmo, yeah if a traitor wants to leave his knife behind for a RANDOM player to pick it up without anyone knowing, then thats fine

[Deacon]

I could see how giving an innocent a knife and "teaming up" would be bad but I would think leaving a knife on the ground to be picked up in certain situations would be a legitimate strategy to cause confusion and disarray in the ranks of the innocents before or while you strike.

this makes sense
not like "oh hey <name> here have fun" and then drop the knife

[This Toast]

Ghosting. You chat with people on steam to know that they are the T. My opinion.

[cogsandspigots]

1. Be innocent
2. Kill T or find knife
3. Throw a knife a the detective with Q
4. 
5. Profit

[Shawn]

I don't think xrain said this and if he did then i'm afraid i would have to disagree.

Xrain did say this he has strictly forbidding me and Bip from banning/kicking anyone from doing this.

[Sabb]

To OP:
What Moo had said.
It's teaming, and isn't allowed.
Many bans were given out for it before.

[ursus]

Has anyone else noticed
>innocent traitors
I'm kind of wondering what Xrain would say.

[Wafflepiezz]

The guy who Xrain told was me. I was playing with somebody and he said in GLOBAL CHAT to come over to him. He dropped his knife right in front of me and gave it to me.
Ghosting = Letting others know who the T's are

In this case, he did NOT tell me anything else. He just said "Here have a knife". I thought he might have been inno, since a T already died and he might have picked the knife up from the dead T. So I didn't kill him for the sakes of my karma.

I can't clarify well at the moment because I'm multi-tasking...someone else please clarify up for me if you have time...

[Seb]

I could see how giving an innocent a knife and "teaming up" would be bad but I would think leaving a knife on the ground to be picked up in certain situations would be a legitimate strategy to cause confusion and disarray in the ranks of the innocents before or while you strike.

That's exactly what happened a few weeks ago.