You guys don't get it.
TL;DR?
RDMers will gain karma very fast using this system.
They will basically kill at least one traitor if they randomly RDM people with high enough karma.
They will not be attacked while detective unless it's by a traitor... who they'll kill anyway.
They will gain karma for each innocent they kill??? I don't think they should.
--> Basically, if we do this, it will help RDMers kill MORE innocents (and possibly traitors) when they are innocent <--
Okay, first off:
What we're proposing is to gain about 10-50 karma for innocent kills as traitor. If you have 10 karma and knife one innocent as traitor, you now have (Potentially) about 90 karma.
Damage reduction is 90% until you bring it up to about 400 karma.
So using this principle, if you killed EVERY SINGLE INNOCENT as traitor, you would gain 13 x 50 karma = 650.
Now let's just imagine this scenario: You are a stubborn, thickheaded, fucking idiot of sorts. You think that all of us "don't get it" and that your logic could not possibly be wrong. Because after all, you're taking AP government. Right guys?