In the realm of classic rock who is better

[StartedBullet]

I wish to see your opinions of 4 classic rock bands. I like them all very much, and will post the albums i have for no reasons at all.

Led Zeppelin:
Led Zeppelin 1-4, physical graffiti, mothership, and a box set.
92 songs total

Pink Floyd:
The Wall 1&2, Echoes 1&2, the dark side of the moon, meddle.
67 songs total

The Beatles:
1, rubber soul, revolver, anthologies, A hard days night, live at BBC, love, let it be (naked), magical mystery tour, Past Masters 1&2
367 songs total

Jimi hendrix ( or the Jimi Hendrix experience ):
The Ultimate Experience, a few from woodstock, one from Waynes World, Electric Ladyland, Smash hits
51 songs

[Cake Faice]

The Beatles. Hands down.

[Alphaggot]

The Beatles. Hands down.

[» Magic «]

the best thing Britain ever created, The Beatles

[Seb]

<---------




I like The Beatles and all, but I really can't find the songs as beautiful and meaningful as Pink Floyd's songs.

[Captain Communism]

Forgive my complete ignorance on the subject, but are The Offspring rock?

I'm more of a techno guy anyways.

[» Magic «]

Forgive my complete ignorance on the subject, but are The Offspring rock?

I'm more of a techno guy anyways.

>classic rock

[Captain Communism]

>classic rock

Point taken.

[Seb]

Forgive my complete ignorance on the subject, but are The Offspring rock?

I'm more of a techno guy anyways.

If you're more of a techno guy, you might like Pink Floyd better.

[ursus]

Pink Floyd and the Beatles are both shitting amazing, I can't vote for either one. The beatles make me feel like I'm on a cloud, but Pink Floyd gives you a feeling that most people can't understand.

And that feeling is of being alone.

And being fine with it.

[Captain Communism]

If you're more of a techno guy, you might like Pink Floyd better.

Ummmm, yeah...

*sends link to the kind of techno listened to, gets shunned forever*

On topic: AC/DC?
Again, forgive any ignorance.

[Seb]

Pink Floyd and the Beatles are both shitting amazing, I can't vote for either one. The beatles make me feel like I'm on a cloud, but Pink Floyd gives you a feeling that most people can't understand.

And that feeling is of being alone.

And being fine with it.

manlytears.png

[StartedBullet]

Has anyone seen The Wall? That was trippy, and oh so flippin' weird.

Anyways, how come so much good classic rock is british?

Wow this is freaky..... I just read a wiki page on Jimi, and i learned he was stationed in the army where I was born, his father was also stationed here  at the same place as mine, and he's part cherokee too...... freaky.

Also, I think I like Pink Floyd the best. Led Zeppellin, Jimi Hendrix, The Beatles are great, but it's just not as deep. ( I don't like the Monkees, that is a joke )
Pink Floyd makes me feel alright even though I believe I'm a piece of shit.

Damn I'm getting maudlin in this post.
Scheiße.

[Dale Feles]

WHERE IS STYX?

Anyways, I like both Pink Floyd and the Beatles. But, I just like Pink Floyd a little bit better, I don't know why.