Bans (Read Only) > Approved

Hi I'm appealing that the unjustified ban wasn't long enough.

<< < (3/5) > >>

Prox:
   I wasn't there but did Dark Pacifist really got banned for knifing an innocent when he himself was a traitor? Now even if he acted like an asshole about it, a 3 week ban is way too long, even 1 week is too much for that. I really do feel like I don't know the whole story and it would be nice to see what ruben has to say about this.

Deathie:

--- Quote from: Prox on February 11, 2013, 02:55:37 AM ---   I wasn't there but did Dark Pacifist really got banned for knifing an innocent when he himself was a traitor?

--- End quote ---

It was more that he announced he was going to revenge RDM before the round started. Considering Darks history, he was going to follow through with it regardless if he was or wasn't a traitor.

Still though, conveniently, he didn't actually break any rules here. I think it's more the intention that people are worried about.

Prox:

--- Quote from: Fleet Commander Hanyuu on February 11, 2013, 03:07:32 AM ---It was more that he announced he was going to revenge RDM before the round started. Considering Darks history, he was going to follow through with it regardless if he was or wasn't a traitor.

Still though, conveniently, he didn't actually break any rules here. I think it's more the intention that people are worried about.

--- End quote ---
Well, I don't think that banning people for something they haven't done is a good idea, well perhaps not in this case since target RDM isn't as bad as a serious Ddos threat for example, but perhaps a warning or a short ban would have been a bit better solution to the problem because a 3 week ban for a regular is not the same as a 3 week ban for someone who just randomly stumbled upon the server just to RDM and don't come back again.

Sabb:
Keep in mind that he was apparently asking to be banned in-game due to binds. Under the circumstances that'd just make him look more like a player purposely trying to cause trouble so...
And of course the only person that knows the other side of the situation is Ruben. He may decide to shorten the ban after understanding the situation a bit more through the thread, might not.

Lazord:
Ruben was pretty busy the whole day fixing stuff on TTT for us and he also dealt with many RDMers and rule breakers along the way.

I'm pretty sure Ruben banned Dark from what he heard and not from what actually happened...

(I'm pretty sure Ruben doesn't know Dark well so there's no way he could've banned Dark from his history)

Dark announced that he was going to Target RDM this guy next round

It was coincidence that he was traitor that round so he knifed the guy he wanted to in the first place. He claimed after the round that he was going for Det.

To put it simply Ruben just banned him because he heard that he killed the guy he said he would (I don't think he checked if Dark was traitor or not, if he had this ban or appeal may have never happened, I don't blame Ruben though)

It's not right to ban somebody for intention like Prox said.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page