And I mean games released in 2012. Not old games you played in 2012.
For me, I only completed a few 2012 games.
I probably say PlayStation All Stars Battle Royale is my GOTY. With The Walking Dead being a close second.(Even though I still barely consider it a game.)
The only other 2012 games I played was AC3, BLOPS2, and KH3D.
I'd say AC3 was my biggest let down just for that ending, retarded combat, and Connor being a whiny annoying bitch.
KH3d gets 2nd place because a few things felt meh to me. A good KH but not a great one.