Report fill out form

[blαh2355]

I've been to some other TTT servers and witnessed and rdmer so I was going to report on their forums when I found this. Can we implement something like this in our reporting section?



This only posts the report on the forum automatically but it's still up for discussion and current rules still apply.

[Lavenchie]

What's wrong with doing the EXACT SAME THING just with a simple copy and paste. Either way they both have to fill out the information and It wouldn't make a difference at all.

[blαh2355]

Well if we implement this we can have a reduction of people making a fail report and force them to fill out this form. For example: http://forum.randomgs.com/index.php/topic,12614.0.html

And this is a bit more tidier imo. It's not gonna hurt us either.

[Travelsonic]

Well if we implement this we can have a reduction of people making a fail report and force them to fill out this form. For example: http://forum.randomgs.com/index.php/topic,12614.0.html

And this is a bit more tidier imo. It's not gonna hurt us either.

True, BUT it also removes the user input not just from the one reporting, but from others who were there, the one being reported, etc - that is not IMO good.

With this system, it seems like THIS report for example would have been approved since you'd only have the evidence the reportee presented, and not get the input from those who pointed out how what happened there wasn't against the rules, the more technical aspects of what happened, etc.

I like the idea of streamlining the process, but if it doesn't give a chance for the accused to reply, for that person - and those who play with him or her - to reply, explain, give counterevidence, then I don't think I'd want it replacing anything. 

[Deacon]

I made a simple copy/paste form for that reason. It is a format we like, while still being a post available for discussion (emphasis on DISCUSSION, not +1)

Its still Here.

[blαh2355]

True, BUT it also removes the user input not just from the one reporting, but from others who were there, the one being reported, etc - that is not IMO good.

With this system, it seems like THIS report for example would have been approved since you'd only have the evidence the reportee presented, and not get the input from those who pointed out how what happened there wasn't against the rules, the more technical aspects of what happened, etc.

I like the idea of streamlining the process, but if it doesn't give a chance for the accused to reply, for that person - and those who play with him or her - to reply, explain, give counterevidence, then I don't think I'd want it replacing anything. 

It would still be posted up for everyone to review, it's just an application for easier posting.

[Travelsonic]

It would still be posted up for everyone to review, it's just an application for easier posting.

... oh. 

[Lazer Blade]

This would be nice to have I support this +1

[aerobro]

Let's save this for later... the current reports aren't even being looked at right now

[Eion Kilant 739]

The current system is fine and we know it works. Now this would generate more coherent reports (from people who don't know how to do it) but we can get the same thing with a little more effort.

[Tezuni]

I like this idea, let's do it.

[Peetah]

We are gunna need a way to discuss it.
Or work off of the amount of complaints.

[YomoFox]

so it was like fillout forrm and copy-paste to forum?
or fill out form + new report management system?

 

[blαh2355]

so it was like fillout forrm and copy-paste to forum?

This

Updated OP for clarification.

[Dale Feles]

I don't see what's wrong with this.

If players want to report someone, they will still have to provide an effort by getting proof + the players steam ID. I'm pretty sure we could make it mandatory to put a steam ID in the form or else it couldn't be posted.